Fact-Checkers Dispute Trump’s Claims About Being Carried to Safety During 9/11 Attacks

As the 25th anniversary of the September 11 attacks approaches, journalists and fact-checkers are scrutinizing Donald Trump’s repeated claims that firefighters carried him to safety during the terrorist strikes. Multiple news outlets have documented discrepancies between his account and verified timelines of the day.

9 Sept, 15:08 — 9 Sept, 19:18

Post Share

Why this matters

As the 25th anniversary of the September 11 attacks approaches, scrutiny of historical narratives intensifies. Verifying the accounts of public figures involved in or commenting on the event is crucial for maintaining accurate historical records and respecting the victims.

Key entitiesDonald Trump New York Times Al-Qaida

The Story

What 9 sources agree on, dispute, and miss

What sources agree on

Donald Trump claimed he was carried to safety by firefighters after the 9/11 attacks
Multiple outlets confirm there is no evidence supporting this claim
The scrutiny coincides with the upcoming 25th anniversary of the attacks

Key claims3 agreed · 1 unverified

✓

Trump claimed firefighters carried him to safety after the 9/11 attacks

agreed·jerusalem-postobservadorindex-hr

✓

There is no evidence supporting Trump's claim that he was carried by firefighters

agreed·jerusalem-postobservadorindex-hr

✓

The New York Times disputed Trump's claim

agreed·jerusalem-post

Trump has made at least six significant falsehoods about 9/11

unverified·The Guardian

Where they diverge

Scope of coverage

The Guardian

Contextualizes the firefighter claim as part of a pattern of six major falsehoods about 9/11

jerusalem-postobservadorindex-hr

Focuses narrowly on the specific new/unsubstantiated claim about being rescued by firefighters

Coverage gaps

Specific details on how Trump responded to the New York Times' dispute via social media

Reportedobservador

Missingjerusalem-postThe Guardianindex-hr

The Story

Analyzing sources…

Source Diversity

Excellent (88/100)

9 sources33/33

Spectrum spread— 4/5 buckets covered25/33

Far L2

Far Left (2)

CNNThe Guardian

Left2

Left (2)

globe-and-mailindex-hr

Center2

Center (2)

tagesschaujutarnji-list

Right3

Right (3)

jerusalem-postobservadorfaz

Far R

Geographic diversity— 7 regions30/34

Germany2Croatia2Canada1Israel1US1Portugal1UK1

Sources

Showing 4 of 9 sources

The GuardianMostly Factual1d ago

Trump’s top six falsehoods about 9/11 as 25th anniversary nears

US president often brings up al-Qaida attack that struck his home town New York City almost 25 years ago Donald Trump often brings up September 11, the devastating al-Qaida attack that struck his home town New York City almost 25 years ago. His recollections of that day have repeatedly included exaggerations and falsehoods – including this week, when he shared an anecdote at a White House event commemorating the attacks that appears to be untrue. Continue reading...

By Chris Stein in Washington

Read full article →

CNNMostly Factual1d ago

Fact check: Trump’s story about being carried away by firefighters after the 9/11 attack - CNN

Fact check: Trump’s story about being carried away by firefighters after the 9/11 attack CNN

Read full article →

globe-and-mailHigh22h ago

The U.S. media is getting soft on Trump in this trade war

Donald Trump and his government are fomenting ugly perceptions about Canada, and we need to push back

By Lawrence Martin

Read full article →

jerusalem-postMostly Factual1d ago

Trump claims firefighters carried him to safety after 9/11 attacks, 'New York Times' disputes

Trump has repeatedly claimed that he assisted after the September 11 terror attack on the World Trade Center, but on Tuesday, he claimed that he was rescued by two firefighters shortly afterward.

Read full article →